GoPro Compared to the Sony HDR-AS15

5

It seems that Sony has taken on the challenge to take away GoPro’s sports camera domination with the HDR-AS15. You want to know what I think?
So I had the chance to see the HDR-AS15 while visiting a technology expo (CEATEC) in Chiba, Japan. As there were many big players from Japan,  I saw a cool looking sports camera made by Sony and at that moment I thought that Sony may have come up with a real competitor to the famed GoPro HD Camera.

However, to my honest opinion, Gopro still has the competitive edge over the HDR-AS15 and this is why.

HDR-AS15 Mounted on Helmet at Tech Expo
At first glance, the HDR-AS15 looks pretty cool in it’s 60 meter waterproof housing case. The dark color of the HD camera and its thin shape manages to help conceal the camera.  But  the most noticeable difference is Sony’s slim aerodynamic shape compared to GoPro’s boxy design.

GoPro’s Boxy Design Is More Versatile Than Sony’s Slim Design.

Remember that both cameras are meant to be worn, mounted, and abused in the name of sports. While, Sony’s HD camera can be attached to helmets, rack mounts, suction cups, and anything the GoPro can mount on, the elongated shape may pose some problems that can be a hazard especially for those who want to mount the camera to their chest and forehead. To prevent injury, I would rather have an object touching my body to be as flat as possible and from what I can conclude you cannot mount the HDR-AS15 to your forehead or to your chest. The closest thing to mounting the AS15 to your forehead is to the side of your head, which I think sucks because you lose one visual side due to your head being in the way… taking away the point of wide angle field of view.

HDR-AS15 without the case

So What Makes The HDR-AS15 Better (Pros)

  1. Built-in Wifi that can be controlled with smart phones (Android and iPhones)
  2. The Apps are  already available to use..
  3. The HD camera uses Zeiss Lens, which are known to be high quality glass.
  4. Uses Exmor CMOS sensor.

Built in WIFI is definitely a big deal to me but it is the only thing I can come up with that makes the HD-AS15 better than the GoPro Hero 2 right now.

HD Quality?

I saw sample videos that were filmed by the HDR-AS15 and I really didn’t see that much of a difference from the GoPro camera. Actually, I thought that  the GoPro Hero 2 was much sharper and had better contrast than the HDR-AS15.

Just to note, Sony’s sports camera can film in HD 720p and 1080p, which is something GoPro has been doing since it released the Hero 1. What makes it a little better is it’s super slowmotion at HD. They don’t say how slow but the wording is 4X slow motion. Also, although 720p and 1080p is nothing new in the HD video world with sports cameras, the video quality seems to be up to par to the competition because Sony’s HD camera uses an Exmor R CMOS sensor and some high quality Zeiss lens. However, I cannot actually say if the use of Zeiss lens and the Exmor Cmos sensor puts it on top of the GoPro camera yet.

How about the size and weight?

The HD AS15 is obviously smaller and slimmer than the Gopro camera. As to weight, Sony’s camera is a bit lighter than the GoPro Hero. Just know that the difference is so small you wouldn’t notice a thing.

Front view of the AS15

Cons Of The HDR-AS15

  1. Charge time to Fully recharge the battery (4 hours compared to GoPro’s 2 hour charge time)
  2. Flimsy battery latch door.
  3. Price (Probably because of the built-in-wifi)
  4. Not as simple to handle as the GoPro Hero

Bottom Line

Both cameras are good and it’s interesting to see a big company try to take on a smaller but well famed company in the HD video world. But the bottom line to me is I prefer the GoPro because it’s cheaper, well established, and well proven among many professionals. Also, I like to add firsthand that the camera is pretty much bombproof that has survived the worst abuse from falling thousands of feet from the air to getting soaked in sea water.

The HDR-AS15 although still new needs to prove itself. Sony’s new camera has similar features but GoPro was the first to implement those features (e.g. wifi, LCD bakpac, wearable functions, and etc.) in their cameras. It seems like Sony is just copying what has already been innovated.

Protected by Copyscape Online Copyright Protection
 

Leave a Reply

5 Comments on "GoPro Compared to the Sony HDR-AS15"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
dirtydog
Guest

Copy Cat Sony
What once used to be a great corporation is now copying others? I don’t think the has15 will come close to dominating the sports came field. I think they’re wasting money on RandD just to compete with gopro. Moody’s downgraded their rating just a while ago!

Btw, thanks for your blogs adamgo. I notice you write many blogs and most are about the Gopro camera. So far I enjoy using my GoPro and have no serious problems with it besides getting it wet. One of your really helpful post help fix that. 😀

Cheers buddy!

adamgo
Guest

you’re welcome
Thanks for the kind words. Also, thanks for the heads up about the moody’s debt rating on Sony.

Glad the wet gopro article worked out for you! I wonder if the HD-AS15 can recover from such as problem?

Toby
Guest

How about 720P at 120FPS?
I hear the deal breaker on sonys new cam is its ability to film 120 fps at 720P. Why didn’t mention anything about that? Or it just a rumor?

adamgo
Guest
720 super slow moThanks for the info Toby. I had to double check on that. In my blog above all I said was super slow motion. It’s interesting because when I was at CEATEC, I asked about this, and the Sony representative said that their cam can film at “super” slow motion at 720p. No other details mentioned. I had to check the Sony website and confirm and it seems that the HDRAS15 can film 120 fps at 720p. In addition, it’s interesting to note that through rumor, GoPro is coming out with the Hero that will have built-in wifi… Read more »
trackback

[…] GoPro’s competitors such as Contour, Sony, and the rest of the crew may have already yielded their heavy-weight belts to GoPro; but the truth is that owning a GoPro is what made GoPro cool to have and rise to the top… […]

wpDiscuz